The Bat
Willie Mays was a force to be reckoned with at the plate. With 660 home runs, he currently holds the sixth spot on the all-time home run list. His career included 3,283 hits, placing him 11th in that category, and he maintained an impressive .302 batting average.
"It was a different sound off his bat. One day I got to the ballpark very early just to check out his bats. I went to the other dugout to see if they were different. They were heavy; they weren't different. He was different," said Bobby Valentine.
"I felt sorry for Willie in a way, having to play at that s---hole Candlestick. If he played today in the bandboxes in Cincinnati and Philadelphia and some other places, he'd hit 70 homers a year. He was a good hitter. He loved to talk hitting," observed Pete Rose.
"Willie didn't like to wait in the box. He wants you to throw the ball right now. One time, I tried to distract him by talking to him. I asked him a question at the plate and, while answering, he hit the ball out of the ballpark. Then he sort of made a half turn to me as he started to first base and told me, 'I'll finish the story later,'" recalled Joe Torre.
The Glove
Mays is equally legendary for his defensive prowess, winning 12 Gold Gloves throughout his career. Many argue he could have won even more. His speed, range, and baseball instincts set him apart in center field.
"He was the best center fielder in the game when he was 39 years old. It's truly amazing how long he was able to maintain his skills," said Steve Stone.
"Curt Flood was the best I've ever seen against the wall. But Curt played deep. Willie didn't play deep; he played shallow. Willie was the wall," noted Tim McCarver.
"Chris Speier told me Willie was calling pitches from center field for the pitcher to throw to a certain hitter. Those guys studied all the hitters back then. They didn't need a scout," commented Baker.
The Arm
Mays' arm strength was another hallmark of his game. His throws were both powerful and accurate, a critical trait for a center fielder.
"You already knew there were guys that you never, ever ran on. You had respect for those guys. Willie charged the ball as well as anyone," admired Bench.
"Johnny Keane, the Cardinals manager, told us in meetings, 'Don't run on Willie, he will throw you out. He's baiting you. He wants you to think he can't, and then he does.' Willie figured it out," recalled Tim McCarver.
"Willie caught the ball at the 390-foot sign in right-center field, and he threw a low throw, on the line, in the air, all the way to third base. Willie had the greatest throwing arm I've ever seen, even better than Roberto Clemente's arm," claimed Orlando Cepeda.
The Legs
Mays' baserunning skills were unparalleled, often setting him apart from other power hitters. His speed and instincts made him a terror on the bases.
"He was a terror on the bases," said Tim McCarver.
"Willie would start to run to second on the wild pitch or a passed ball. Willie had great instincts on the bases," observed Baker.
"You can say 29th in steals when he retired, but he could have easily moved into the top 10," noted Bench.
"Oh, hell, 40-40, that's nothing. I could have done 50-50 any time. I wanted to steal my bases when it mattered, for the team," remarked Jackson.
"The greatest baserunner I've ever seen. I tried to mimic him, to do what he did on the bases. But I couldn't. No one could," admitted Orlando Cepeda.
The Say Hey Kid
Beyond his talents on the field, Willie Mays was known for his charisma and character. Revered by teammates and opponents alike, he left a lasting impression on everyone he met.
"The first time I met him I was 17, playing in the Instructional League. I missed the first two innings of the game because I was talking to Willie Mays. But my manager didn't care. He said, 'He's going to learn more talking to Willie Mays than he's going to learn playing in his damn game today. Let him talk as long as he likes,'" recalled Ken Griffey Jr.
"Willie came to the door and said, 'Who is this?' Bill said, 'Willie, this is Bob Gibson.' Willie didn't say hello, he said, 'You wear glasses!? And you don't wear them when you pitch? Are you crazy? You're going to hurt somebody!'" remembered Joe Torre.
"The first time I met Willie was the day I was called up to the big leagues. He was so good to me, but he was so good to everyone," said Juan Marichal.
"My rookie year in spring training, Willie came over to the A's bench and said, 'Where's Reggie Jackson? I want to see Reggie Jackson.' I met him. That was a huge deal for me, for him to come to our dugout and ask for me. I got to shake his hand," shared Reggie Jackson.
"I wrote in my book that Willie had the thickest fingers I have ever seen, and he buffed his fingernails every day. He came up to me and said, in that high-pitched voice, 'I heard that you said that I buffed my nails every day. You're right, I do!'" chuckled Tim McCarver.
Willie Mays was not just a player; he was an influential force in baseball. His talents spanned every aspect of the game, from hitting to fielding, throwing, and running. But beyond statistics and accolades, it was his unique personality and love for the game that left an indelible mark on all who had the pleasure to watch or play alongside him. In every sense, Willie Mays was, and remains, the epitome of a baseball legend.